I hated my 2005 Golf, I found the ride too soft and the cabin was really cheap. Also was the most unreliable car I've ever owned, and I've owned Alfa's!
Much much happier with the Civic, ride is much more too my liking, although I do like a nice firm ride! Also the
Vtec engine in the 1.8 is great for me as it loves to rev, much like my old Alfa.
Golf for me was boring, unreliable and a chore to drive.
And how can they put the 1 series second?? It's sooo over priced, especially if you want anything other than just the basics.
Hmm... maybe I should write for what car!